Abuse of Creative Accounting Practices at Satyam Computer Services Limited: A Tale of India’s Enron.

Author(s)

Dr. Madan Lal Bhasin ,

Download Full PDF Pages: 01-24 | Views: 374 | Downloads: 109 | DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3464783

Volume 5 - June 2016 (06)

Abstract

Creative accounting (CA) involves the „manipulation‟ of company financial records towards a „pre-determined‟ target. Unfortunately, few „loopholes‟ in the accounting standards provide enough room for the use of CA practices. Satyam‟s case has been widely regarded as the debacle of the Indian financial system, which is very often referred to as India‟s „Enron‟. Unlike Enron, which sank due to „agency‟ problem, Satyam was brought to its knee due to „tunneling‟ effect. Keen to project a perpetually rosy picture of the company to the investors, employees and analysts, Raju manipulated the account books so that it appeared a far bigger enterprise than it actually was. The present study provides a „snapshot‟ of how Mr. Raju, CEO and Chairman of Satyam, „mastermind‟ this maze of CA? Undoubtedly, Satyam scam is clearly a case of abuse of CA, in which the accounts were manipulated by creating fake invoices, inflating revenues, falsifying the cash and bank balances, showing non-existent interest on fixed deposits, showing ghost employees, and so on. This type of CA is both illegal and unethical. In its recent indictment of the former promoters and top managers of Satyam, various investigative agencies (viz., SEBI, CBI, CID, SFIO, etc.) in India had finally provided minute and fascinating details about how India‟s largest corporate scam was committed. An attempt has been made by the author, based on media reports, to provide a description about the CA methodology used by the Satyam to commit the accounting fraud, duly supported by evidence wherever possible. An attempt has been made to provide an explanation for various „intriguing‟ questions, such as: What was the need to commit a fraud on such a large scale?, How Raju managed to cooked up Satyam books?, What was Raju‟s real modus operandi to manipulate the accounts for eight years?, Why was Raju forced to blow his own whistle?, Why was not there a stricter punitive action against the auditors of Satyam PwC?” After thorough investigations, both the CBI and SEBI have revealed the manner in which the Satyam fraud was engineered. We recommend that “CA practices should be considered as a serious crime, and as such, accounting bodies, law courts and other regulatory authorities need to adopt very strict punitive measures to stop unethical CA practices.”  

Keywords

Creative Accounting, Satyam Computer, Financial Statements, Corporate Governance, Forensic Accounting, SEBI, SFIO, CID, India.

References

  1. Agrawal, S. and Sharma, R. (2009), Beat this: Satyam won awards for corporate governance, internal audit. Available at www.vccircle.com/news.
  2. Ahmad, T., Malawat, T., Kochar, Y. and Roy, A. (2010), Satyam Scam in the Contemporary corporate world: A case study in Indian Perspective, IUP Journal. Available at SSRN, 1-48.
  3. Amat, O., Blake, J., and Dowds, J. (1999). The ethics of creative accounting, Economics Working Paper, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, available at econ-papers.
  4. Baralexis, S. (2004). Creative accounting in small advancing countries: the Greek case, Managerial Auditing Journal, 19(3), 440-461.
  5. Bhasin, M.L. (2008), Corporate Governance and Role of the Forensic Accountant, The Chartered Secretary Journal, Vol. 38(10), October, 1361-1368.
  6. Bhasin, M.L. (2010), Corporate Governance Disclosure Practices: The Portrait of a Developing Country, International Journal of Business and Management, 5(4), April, 150-167.
  7. Bhasin, M.L. (2011),Corporate Governance Disclosure Practices: The Portrait of a Developing Country, International Review of Business Research Papers, 7(1), January, 393-419.
  8. Bhasin, M.L. (2012), Corporate Accounting Frauds: A Case Study of Satyam Computers Limited, International Journal of Contemporary Business Studies, Oct., Volume 3, No. 10, pp. 16-42.
  9. Bhasin, M.L. (2013), Corporate Accounting Scandal at Satyam: A Case Study of India‟s Enron, European Journal of Business and Social Sciences, 1(12), March, 25-47.
  10. Bhasin, M.L. (2013a), Corporate Accounting Fraud: A Case Study of Satyam Computer Limited, Open Journal of Accounting, April, 2(2), 26-38.
  11. Bhasin, M.L. (2013b), Corporate Governance and Role of the Forensic Accountant: an exploratory study of an Asian country, Amity Business Review, 14(1), Jan-June, 48-71.
  12. Bhasin, M.L. (2015). Forensic Accounting: Perspectives and Prospects, Pakistan Accountant, July-Sept.
  13. Bhasin, M.L. (2015a), Menace of Frauds in Banking Industry: Experience of a Developing Country, Australian Journal of Business and Management Research, 4(12), April, 21-33.
  14. Bhasin, M.L. (2015b), Creative Accounting Practices in the Indian Corporate Sector: An Empirical Study, International Journal of Management Science and Business Research, Volume 4, Issue 10, October, 35-52.
  15. Bhasin, M.L. (2016), Debacle of Satyam Computers Limited: A Case Study of India‟s Enron, Wulfenia Journal KLAGENFURT, 23(3), March, 124-162.
  16. Bhasin, M.L. (2016a), Contribution of Forensic Accounting to Corporate Governance: An Exploratory Study of an Asian Country, International Business Management, 10(4), 479-492.
  17. Bhasin, M.L. (2016b), Survey of Creative Accounting Practices: An Empirical Study, Wulfenia Journal KLAGENFURT, 23(1), January, 143-162.
  18. Bhasin, M.L. (2016c), Strengthening Corporate Governance Through an Audit Committee: An Empirical Study, Wulfenia Journal, Volume 23, No. 2, Feb. pp. 2-27.
  19. Blakely, R. (2009). Investors raise questions over PWC Satyam audit, Times Online.
  20. Blessing, I.N. (2015). Empirical analysis on the use of forensic accounting techniques in curbing creative accounting, International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management, 3(1), Jan. 1-20.
  21. Chakrabarti, R., Megginson, W., Yadav and Pradeep K. (2008). Corporate Governance in India, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 20(1), 59.
  22. Chopra, A. (2011), Satyam fraud, not an accounting failure, Business Standard, 25 January. Available at http://www.businessstandard.com.
  23. D‟Monte, L. (2008). Satyam: just what went wrong? Rediff India Abroad.
  24. Dixit, N. (2009), What Happened at Satyam? March 1, available at Wharton@knowledge.com.
  25. Fernando, A.C. (2010), Satyam: Anything but Satyam, Loyala Institute of Business Administration. Available at www.publishingindia.com.
  26. Goel, R. and Ansari, A.A. (2015). Abuse of creative accounting: a case study of Satyam computer services ltd. Research Journal of Commerce & Behavioral Science, 4(3) Jan, 65-70.
  27. ICAI (2009). ICAI finds ex Satyam CFO, Price Waterhouse auditors guilty. Outlook India.com.
  28. ICAI (2014), “Institute of Chartered Accountants of India ” has imposed a life-time ban on four auditors, April 22
  29. Jawad, F.A. and Xia, X. (2015). International financial reporting standards and moral hazard of creative accounting on hedging, International Journal of Finance and Accounting, 4(1), 60-70.
  30. Jones, M. (2011). Creative accounting, fraud and international accounting scandals, John Wiley & Sons, London.
  31. Khedekar, D. (2010), Corporate Crime: a comparison of culture at Enron and Satyam, Economics & Business Journal: Inquiries and Perspectives, 3(1) Oct. 156-175.
  32. Kripalani, M. (2009). India‟s Madoff Satyam scandal rocks outsourcing industry. Business Week.
  33. Kahn, J. (2009). The Crisis exposes all the flaws. Newsweek.
  34. Kaul, V. (2015), Satyam scam: Ramalinga Raju, the man who knew too much, gets 7 years in jail, April 10.
  35. Krishnan, A. (2014), Finally, the truth about Satyam, The Hindu Business Line, July 18.
  36. Kumar, G., Paul, P. and Sapkota, P. (2012), The largest corporate fraud in India: Satyam Computer Services Limited, International Journal of Critical Accounting, 4(4), 21-36.
  37. Knezevic, G., Mizdrakovic, V. and Arezina, N. (2012). Management as cause and instrument of creative accounting suppression, Journal for Theory and Practice of Management, 103-110.
  38. Micah, L.C. and Chinwe, O.E. (2014). The impact of creative accounting on organizational effectiveness: a study of manufacturing firms in Nigeria, British Journal of Economics, Management & Trade, 4(12).
  39. Miller, G.S. (2006), The press as a watchdog for accounting fraud, Journal of Accounting Research, 44(5), December, 1001- 1033.
  40. Momani, M.A. and Obeidat, M.I. (2013). The effect of auditors‟ ethics on their detection of creative accounting practices: a field study, International Journal of Business and Management, 8(13), 118-135.
  41. Mulford, C.W. and Comiskey, E.E. (2005). Financial numbers game: detecting creative accounting practices, John Wiley & Sons, London.
  42. Nag, A.K. (2015). Is creative accounting ethical: an analysis into pros and cons, Indian Journal of Applied Research, 5(2),Feb.83-84.
  43. Norris, F. (2011), Indian Accounting Firm is Fined $7.5 million over fraud at Satyam, The New York Times, Apr 5.
  44. Niazi, A. and Ali, M. (2015), The Debacle of Satyam Computers Ltd.: A Case Study from Management‟s Perspective, Universal Journal of Industrial and Business Management, 3(2), 58-65.
  45. Osazevbaru, H.O. (2012). Creative accounting and firms‟ market value in Nigeria, Kuwait Chapter of Arabian Journal of Business and Management Review, 2(3), 35-50.
  46. Pai, K. and Tollesen, T.D. (2015), India‟s Satyam Scandal
  47. Patnaik, B.C.M., Satpathy, I. and Das, C. (2014), Creative accounting @window dressing: an empirical analysis, International Journal of Management, 5(2), Feb. 61-68.
  48. Pai, K. and Tollesen, T.D. (2015), India‟s Satyam Scandal: Evidence too large to Indict Mindset of Accounting Regulators is a Global Phenomenon, Review of Business and Financial Studies, 6(2), 35-43.
  49. Ramana, K.V. (2009), “7,561 fake invoices = Rs. 5,117 crore „Sales‟,” April 15, DNA. Available at http://www.dnaindia.com.
  50. Ramachadran, S. (2009). Raju brings down Satyam, shakes India. Asia Times Online Ltd. SFIO Report published in the Pioneer (New Delhi), May 4, 2009, p 10
  51. Renu & Aggarwal (2014). Creative accounting: a negative aspect of accounting, International Journal of Applied Research Studies, 3(5), 1-8.
  52. Sanusi, B. and Izedonmi, P.F. (2014). Nigerian commercial banks and creative accounting practices, Journal of Mathematical Finance, 4, 75-83.
  53. Sharma, J.P. (2015), What went wrong with Satyam? Paper presented at WCFCG Global Convention, in association with Institute of Directors, available at www.iodonline.com.
  54. Shah, A.K. (1998). Exploring the influences and constraints on creative accounting in the UK, The European Accounting Review, 7(1), 83-104.
  55. SFIO (2009), SFIO Report published in the Pioneer (New Delhi), May 4, 2009, p 10
  56. Shirur, S. (2011), “Tunneling vs. agency effect: a case study of Enron and Satyam,” Vikalpa, 36(3), July-Sept, 9-20.
  57. Shubhashish (2015), “All that you need to know about the Satyam Scam,” DNA, April 9.
  58. Susmus, T. and Demirhan, D. (2013). Creative accounting: a brief history and conceptual framework, Paper presented at “3rd Balkans and Middle East Countries Conference on Accounting,” between 19-22 June, 2013.
  59. Tassadaq, F. and Malik, Q.A. (2015). Creative accounting and financial reporting: model development and empirical testing, International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 5(2), 544-551.
  60. Timmons, H. and Wassener, B. (2009), “Satyam chief admits huge fraud,” January 8, New York Times Online, available at www.nytimes.com.
  61. Vasudev, P.M. (2010), Satyam and Enron: A Tale of two companies and two countries, Sept. 14, Deccan Herald, available at http://www.deccanherald.com/content/96271/satyam-amp-enron-tale-two.html.
  62. Veena L. Brown, Brian E. Daugherty, and Julie S. Persellin (2014) Satyam Fraud: A Case Study of India's Enron. Issues in Accounting Education: August 2014, Vol. 29, No. 3, pp. 419-442.
  63. Verma, R. (2009), Satyam fraud methodology revealed, April 29. Available at www.accountancyage.com.
  64. Vyas, A.H., Ambadkar, R. and Bhargave, J. (2015). True and fair view: a fact or illusion in the world of creative accounting, International Journal of Multidisciplinary and Current Research, 3, May/June, 572-575.
  65. Wang, C. (2008). A close examination on creative accounting from theoretical, practical and subjective perspectives, Unpublished Thesis of MA in Finance and Accounting, University of Nottingham.
  66. Winkler, D. (2010), India‟s Satyam Accounting Scandal, February 1, The University of Iowa Center for International Finance and Development. Available online at http://blogs.law.uiowa.edu.
  67. Wharton (2009), Scandal at Satyam: Truth, Lies and Corporate Governance, available at knowledge@wharton.

Cite this Article: