Analysis of the Association of Foreign Debt with Macro Economic Variables and View of Islamic Economy: Study of the Indonesian State Budget Period 1968-2018 Using Vector Autoregression (VAR) Method and Tawhidi String Relation (TSR)


Masfar Gazali , Yuswar Zainul Basri , R. Bambang Budhijana ,

Download Full PDF Pages: 168-201 | Views: 772 | Downloads: 238 | DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3510032

Volume 8 - July 2019 (07)


This study aims to look at the state budget deficit and the effect of foreign debt on macroeconomic variables. These variables are economic growth, domestic savings, investment, exports, labor force growth and Indonesia's GDP. Zakat is used for the possibility of being used as a funding source to cover existing budget deficits. This study also looks at the interrelationship (causality) of the influence of foreign debt with macroeconomic variables as above. The methods used are Vector Autoregressive (VAR) and Tawhidi String Relations (TSR). These methods are used simultaneously, namely applying the VAR method to TSR. Also proposed is the variable zakat as the financing for the budget deficit that occurs. That the budget deficit was caused by an imbalance between the state's sources of income and government expenditure. To find that this government deficit is refinanced by adding new debt, both foreign debt and domestic debt. Resulting,  that the existing debt becomes burdens the State in the installment process, both principal and interest. Another finding from this study all variables studied have a causal relationship with each other. Only 8 variables related to one direction are economic growth and debt, FDI with saving. Then exports with debt, debt and labor force, saving and also GDP per capita and debt and labor force also saving. When these findings were applied to the TSR method, the results showed better results and conditions. This study also found that the variable zakat as an Islamic economic variable can and able to cover the budget deficit that occurs in the APBN, as seen from the large potential of existing zakat which is Rp. 217 trillion per year. But if this zakat is applied to APBN, it must be channeled to a minimum of 4 categories who are eligible as recipients of zakat according to Islamic law. The implication of this finding is that the government pays attention to variables that affect other variables and also the nature of causality. Meanwhile, zakat can be managed more professionally because it has greater potential at least to be used as an alleviation of poverty and poverty as two becomes variables of zakat recipients that can be submitted to APBN revenues


deficit, budget, foreign debt, economic growth, saving, investment, GDP per capita, unemployment rate, exports, zakat. VAR and TSR.


         i.        Adam, C. S., and D. L. Bevan, (2005). Fiscal Deficits and Growth in Developing   Countries, Journal of Public Economics, Volume 89, pp: 571-597, available at

ii.      Adrian, Tobias, Nina Boyarchenko, dan Domenico Giannone,. (2019). Vulnerable Growth, American Economic Review, Vol. 109. No. 4

iii.    Alfredo S., (2004). Debt and Economic Growth in Developing and Industrial Countries, Working Papers 2005:34, Department of Economics, Lund University, Available at

iv.    Alesina A. and S. Ardagna, (2010).Large Changes in Fiscal Policy: Taxes versus Spending, Tax Policy and the Economy.

v.      Alesina A., C. Favero and F. Giavazzi, (2012).The output effects of fiscal adjustments,  NBER Working Paper, No 18336.

vi.    Alkinson, A.B. and J.E. Stiglitz, (1980), Lecture on Public Economics, McGraw Hill, New York

vii.  Ali, Sharafat. and Imran Sharif Choudhry (2014). External Debt and Domestic Investment in Pakistan: A Cointegration Analysis, Developing Country Studies, Vol 4. No. 16.

viii.Al-Zeaud, Hussein Ali (2014). Public Debt and Economic Growth: An Emperical Assessment, European Scientific Journal, February.

ix.    Arief, Sritua, (1998a). Teori Dan Kebijaksanaan Pembangunan, CIDES, Jakarta.

x.       ---------- (1998b). Pembangunanisme Dan Ekonomi Indonesia Pemberdayaan Rakyat           Dalam Arus

a.      Globalisasi, CPSM, Jakarta.

xi.     Arief, Sritua dan Adi Sasono, (1987).Modal Asing, Beban Hutang Luar Negeri Dan             Ekonomi

a.      Indonesia, LSP dan UI Press, Jakarta.

xii.  Arndt, H.W.(1984) dalam The Indonesian Economy: Collected Papers, ANU Press, Australia

xiii.Arrow, Kenneth. J. And F.H. Hand. (1991). General Competitive Analysis, Holden Day,

a.       San Fransisco.

xiv.Aschauer, D.A. (1989), Is Public Expenditure Productive?,Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 23.

xv.  Ash-Shawi, Shalah dan Abdullah Al-Mushlih, (2004),“Fikih Ekonomi Keuangan Islam”, Darul

a.       Haq, Jakarta.

xvi. Aswicahyono, Haryo, (1996a). “Transformasi Industri: Makna Dan Tantangan”, dalam        “Transformasi

a.       Industri Indonesia Dalam Era Perdagangan Bebas”, Penyunting Mari Pangestu,       Raymond Atje

b.      dan Julius Mulyadi, CSIS, Jakarta.

xvii.                      ---------- “Dari Substitusi Impor ke Promosi Ekspor”, dalam “Transformasi Industri   Indonesia Dalam Era Perdagangan Bebas”, Penyunting Mari Pangestu, Raymond        Atje dan Julius

a.       Mulyadi, CSIS, Jakarta.

xviii.                    Azam, Muhammad., Chandra Emirullah., A.C. Prabhakar and A.Qayyum Khan. (2013).  The Role of External Debt in Economic Growth of Indonesia – A Blessing or Burden?,World Applied Sciences Journal, 25 (8),

xix.Badan Pusat Statistik, 2010 up to 2018.

xx.  Baldacci, Emanuele dan Manmohan S. Kumar (2010).Fiscal Defisit, Public Debt and Sovereign Bond Yield, IMF Working Paper – WP/10/184.

xxi. Barro, Robert J., (1989).The Ricardian Approach to Budget Deficit, Journal of Economic Perspective, Vol. 3.

xxii.                      ---------- (1990). Government Spending in a Simple Model of Endogenous Growth, Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 98.

xxiii.                    ---------- (2000).Macroeconomics, 5th Edition, John Wiley & Sons.

xxiv.                    Barro, Robert J., and Sala-I-Martin, X., (1992). Public Finance in Models of Economic Growth, Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 59.

xxv.                      ---------- (2003). Economic Growth. 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York.

xxvi.                    Basri, Yuswar Z., (2003). Dilematika Ekonomi Ketergantungan (Sebuah Pemikiran),            Rajawali Press.

xxvii.                  Basri, Faisal, (1997). Perekonomian Indonesia Menjelang Abad XXI Distorsi, Peluang         Dan Kendala,

a.      Erlangga, Jakarta.

xxviii.                ---------- (2001). Nestapa UKM jangan Cuma Sekadar Retorika Politik”, 12 Maret , Harian Kompas.

xxix.                    ---------- (2002). Perekenomian Indonesia: Tantangan dan Harapan bagi Kebangkitan                     Bangsa,

a.      Erlangga, Jakarta.

xxx.                        Beckerman, Paul, (2005). How Small Should an Economy’s Fiscal Defisit Be?, The World Bank  Research Paper.

xxxi.                    Beaugrand, Philippe. Boileau Loko and Montfort Mlachila. (2012). The Choice Between External and Domestic Debt in Financing Budget Deficit: The Case of Central and West African Countries, IMF Working Paper – 02/79 May.

xxxii.                  Bi, Huixin. WenyiShen and Shu-Chun S. Young (2014). Fiscal Limits, External Debt, and Fiscal Policy in Developing Countries, IMF Working Paper – 14/49 March.

xxxiii.                Blanchard, O. J. (1985). Debt, deficits, and finite horizons, Journal of Political Economy 93, 223–247.

xxxiv.                  ----------, (2019). Public Debt and Low Ineterst Rates. American Economic Review, Vol. 109. No.4.

xxxv.                  Blanchard, O. J. and Fisher, Stanley, (1989). Lectures on Macroeconomics, Cambridge        Mass, MIT

a.       Press.

xxxvi.                  Blinder, Alan S. and Robert M. Solow (2003). Does Fiscal Policy Matter?, Journal of Public Economics Vol 30. No. 2.

xxxvii.              Brauninger, Michael, (2005). The Budget Deficit, Public Debt, and Endogenous Growth, Journal of Public Economic Theory, Vol. 7.

xxxviii.            Bleaney, M. F e t al. (2001). Testing the Endogenous Growth Model: Public Expenditure, Taxation and Growth over the Long- Run, Canadian Journal ofEconomics, Vol. 34, No.1, pp: 36–57.

xxxix.                Bose, N., M.E. Haque, and D.R. Osborn,(2007). Public expenditure and economic growth: A disaggregated analysis for developing countries, The Manchester School, Vol.75, No.5, pp: 533-556.

xl.    Brender, A. and A. Drazen, (2008). How do budget deficits and economic growth affect reelection prospects? Evidence from a large panel of countries, American Economic Review, Vol.98, No.5, pp: 2203-2220.

xli.  Both, Anne dan Peter McCowley, (1981). Kebijaksanaan Fiskal dalam “Ekonomi Orde Baru”          Penyunting: Anne Both dan Peter McCowley, LP3ES, Jakarta.

xlii. Catao, L. A. V. and Terrones, M. E. (2005). Fiscal deficits and inflation, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 52, pp: 529–554.

xliii.                      Chand, S.K. 1977. Summary Measures of Fiscal Influence. International Monetary Fund Stalf Paper. Vol' 24, No. 2, Juli: 405-449.

xliv.                      Chelliah, R.J. 1978. Significance of Alternative Concepts of Budget Deficit.International Monetary Fund Stalf Paper. Vol. 25, No. 3, November:741-784.

xlv.Chenery, Hoolis B. and Nicholas G. Carter, (1973). Foreign Assistance and Development Performance 1960-1970, American Economic Review, Vol. 63. No. 2.

xlvi.                      Choudhury, M. A., (1993). Comparative Development Studies in Search of New World         View,St. Martin

a.      Press.

xlvii.                    ---------- (1998). Studies in Islamic Social Sciences, London, Eng: Macmillan & New            York:

a.       St.Martin‟s.

xlviii.                   ---------- (1999). Comparative economic theory – Occidental and Islamic Perpsectives,         Klewer Academic Publisher.

xlix.                       ---------- (1999b). Globally interactive systems, in his Comparative Economic Theory: Occidental and

a.       Islamic Perspectives, Norwell, Massachusetts: Kluwer Academic.

l.        ---------- (2002). A Qur‟anic methodology of socio-scientific investigation, in Explaining  the Qur’an,a

a.       Socio-Scientific Inquiry, Book I, Chapter 4, pp.399-452, Lewiston, N.Y: The Edwin Mellen Press.

li.      ---------- (2004a). The Islamic World-system A study in polity-market interaction,       Routledge Curzon.

lii.    ---------- (2013). Handbook of Tawhidi Methodology: Economics, Finance, Society and        Science,

a.       Penerbit Univeristas Trisakti, Jakarta.

liii.  Choudhury, M.A and Hossain, M.S., (2006) Evolutionary Epistemology and Development Planning, Lewiston, New York: The EdwiMellen Press.

liv.  Clark, Will. and Birgir Arnason. (2014). Surging Investment and Declining Aid: Evaluating Debt Sustainability in Rwanda. IMF Working Paper – 14/51 March.

lv.     Cohen, S.S. dan J. Zysman (1987).  Manufacturing Matters: The Myth of the Post-Industrial Economy, Basic Books, New York.

lvi.  De La Granville, Olivier (2005), The 1950 Contribution to Economic Growth Theory by Robert Solow: a Major Landmark and Some of its Undiscovered Riches, Working Paper, University of Geneva.

lvii.Departemen Keuangan Republik Indonesia, APBN (berbagai edisi).

lviii.                      De Silva, Indunil dan Sudarno Sumarto (2014). Does Economic Growth Really Benefit the Poor? Income Distribution Dynamics and Pro-Poor Growth in Indonesia, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol. 50. No. 2.

lix.   Diamond, P. A. (1965). National debt in a neoclassical growth model, American Economic Review 55, 1126–1150.

lx.    Dornbusch, Rudiger and Stanley Fischer. (2010). Macroeconomics, 11th, Edition, McGraw-Hill.

lxi.  Dowling Jr. J. Malcolm and U. Hiemenz, (1983). Aid, Saving and Growth in the Asia Region, Developing Economies, Vol. 21. No. 1.

lxii.Eaton, Jonathan, (1990). Debt Relief and the International and Enforcement of Contracts, Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 4. No. 1.

lxiii.                       Engen, Eric M., dan R. Glenn Hubbard. (2004). Federal Government Debt and Interest Rates, NBER Working Paper No. 1068 (Cambriedge, Massachussets: National Bureau of Economic Research).

lxiv.                      Easterly, W. & S. Rebelo, (1993). Fiscal policy and economic growth: An empirical investigation, Journal of Monetary Economics, Elsevier, Vol. 32, No.3, pp: 417-458.

lxv.Easterly, W. et al. (1994). Public Sector Deficits and Macroeconomic Performance, Oxford and      New

a.      York: Oxford University Pressfor the World Bank.

lxvi.                      Eisner, R. and P. J. Pierper, (1984). A New View of the Federal Debt and Budget Deficits, American Economic Review, Vol. 74, No.1, pp: 11-29.

lxvii.                    Elias, Samuel and Abebe Worku, (2015). Casual Relationship Between Gross Domestic Saving and Economy Growth in East Africa: Evidence From Ethopian, Uganda and Kenya, Journal of Agriculture and Social Research, Vol. 15. No 2, pp: 220-235.

lxviii.                  Forgha, NG. Mukete E. Mbella and Forbe H. Ngangnchi, (2014). External Debt, Domestic Investment and Economic Growth in Cameroon A System Estimation Approach, Journal of Economics Bibliography, Vol. 1. December.

lxix.                       Feder, Gershon, (1983), On Export and Economic Growth, Journal of Development Economics, Vol. 12.

lxx.Gale, William G, dan Peter R. Orzag, (2002). The Economic Effects of Long-Terms Fiscal Disipline, Tax Policy Center Discussion Paper, December.

lxxi.                      Garcia-Jimenez, Carles I. and Ashok K. Mishra, (2010), The Effect of Public Debt on Labor Demand in the USA, The Southern Agriculture Economics Association, Annual Meeting, Orlando, Florida, February.

lxxii.                    Garnout, Ross (2015). Indonesia’s Resources Boom in International Perspective: Policy Dilemmas and Options for Continued Strong Growth, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol 51 No.2.

lxxiii.                  Gazali, Masfar, (2011), “Zakat Mal dan Pemberdayaan Ekonomi Umat”, Republika, 24 Juni. Jakarta

lxxiv.                  Goher Fatima, Ather Maqsood Ahmed, and Wali Ur Rehman (2011). Fiscal Deficit and Economic Growth: An Analysis of Pakistan’s Economy, International Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance, Vol. 2, No. 6, pp: 501-504.

lxxv.                    Granger, CWJ.,(1969), Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectra Methods, Econometrica, Vol. hal. 424-438.

lxxvi.                  Green, H. Williem, (2012), Econometric Analysis, 7th Edition, Prentice Hall.

lxxvii.                Griffin, Keith and J.L. Enos, (1970). Foreign Assistance: Objective and Consequences, Economic Development and Culture Change, Vol. 18.

lxxviii.              Hanke, John. E. dan Dean W. Wichern. 2005. Business Forecasting. Pearson Prentice Hall

lxxix.                  Hansen, E. Bruce,. (2016). Econometrics, Wisconsin University Press.

lxxx.                      Harinowo, C.  (2002). Dalam Utang Pemerintah: Perkembangan, Prospek, dan Pengelolaannya,             Gramedia. Jakarta.

lxxxi.                    Helpman, Elhanan, (1992). Endogenous Macroeconomics Growth Theory, European Economic Growth, No. 36.

lxxxii.                Hojman, D.E., (1986). The External Debt Contribution to Output, Employment, Productivity and Consumption: A Model and An Application to Chile, Economic Modelling.

lxxxiii.                Hubbard, Glenn. (2012). Consequences of Government Deficits and Debt, International Journal of Central Banking, January.

lxxxiv.              Huntley, Jonathan (2014). The Long Run Effect of Federal Budget Deficits on National Saving and Private Investment, Working Paper Series Congresional Budget Office, Washington.

lxxxv.                  Iamsisaroj, Sasi and Hristos Doncouliagos (2015). Does Growth Attrack FDI, Economic the Open-Acess, E-Journal,

lxxxvi.              IMF, Financial Statistic, ssseveral issue.

lxxxvii.            Jorge Avila (2011). Fiscal Deficit, Macro-Uncertainty, and Growth in Argentina, available at 456.pdf. CEMA Working Papers no-456.

lxxxviii.          Kaneko, Yukio dan Nirihisa Sakurai (1990). Dual Structure of the Indonesian Economy An Application of the Input-Output Model by size of Firm”, makalah pada The International Symposium on Economic Modelling, University of Urbino, Italia.

lxxxix.              Keho, Y., (2010). Budget Deficits and Economic Growth: Causality Evidence and Policy Implications for AEMU Countries, European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences, Issue 18, ISSN 1450-2275, pp: 99-104.

xc.   Kinoshita, Noriaki, (2006). Government Debt and Long-Term Interest Rate,  IMF Worlong Paper 06/63 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).

xci. Kompas, “Menatap Indonesia 2014”. Gramedia, Jakarta.

xcii.                       Kurniawati (2004). Kedermawan Kaum Muslimin Potensi dan Realita Zakat Masyarakat      di Indonesia

a.      Hasil Survey di Sepuluh Kota. Piramedia, Jakarta.

xciii.                     Lewis, Blande D. (2014). Indonesian Intergovermental Performance Grants: An Empirical Assesement of Impact. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol. 50. No. 3. Desember 2014. hal. 415-434.

xciv.                     Lipsey, Robert E., dan Frederick Sjoholm. (2011). FDI and Growth in East Asia: Lesson for Indonesia. Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 47. No. 1.

xcv.                       Lindblad, J. Thomas (2015). Foreign Direct Investment in Indonesia: Fifty Year of Discourse, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol. 51. No. 2.

xcvi.                     Lucas, R. E. (2015). Human Capital and Growth, American Economic Review, 105 (5), 85-88.

xcvii.                   ----------, (1988). On the mechanics of economic development, Journal of Monetary Economics 22, 2–42.

xcviii.                  Mack, Andrew. (2001). Rethinking the Dynamics of Capital Accumulation in Colonial and Post-Colonial Indonesia: Production Regulation. University of Sydney

xcix.                     Mahadika, Iman Naufal, Salih Kalayci and Nihal Altum, (2017). Relationship Between GDP, FDI and Export Volume: Evidence From Indonesia, Vol. 8 No.1. February.

c.       Malinvaud, E. (1995), Lectures on Microeconomic Theory, Elsevier Publisher, Holland.

ci.     Mankiw, N. Gregory (2017), Macroeconomics, 7th Edition, Worths Publisher, USA.

cii.   Marks, Stephen V., (2015), The Asean – China Free Trade Agreement: Political Economy of Indonesia, Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 51. No. 2.

ciii. Marks, Stephen V., dan Sjamsu Rahardja. (2012), Effective Rates of Protection Revised for Indonesia, Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 47. No. 1.

civ. McDonald, D.C., (1982). Debt, Capacity and Developing Country Borrowing: A Survey of Literature, IMF Staff Papers, Vol. 29.

cv.   McLeod, Ross H, (1994). Indonesian Foreign Debt, in Ross H. McLeod (ed.), Indonesian     Assessment 1994: Finance as a Key Sector in Indonesia’s Development, Research         School

a.      of Pacific and Asian Studies, Canberra, and Institute of Southeast Asia          Studies, Singapore.

cvi. McLeod, Ross H, (1996). Indonesian Foreign Debt: A Comment, Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 32. No. 2.

cvii.                       Nelson, M. A. and Singh, R. D. (1994). The Deficit-Growth Connection: Some Recent Evidence from Developing Countries, Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 43, No.1, pp:167-191.

cviii.                     Osinubi, T. S., and, O. E. Olaleru, (2010). Budget Deficits, External Debt and Economic Growth In Nigeria, The Singapore Economic Review, Vol. 55, No. 3, pp. 491–521.

cix. Osuka, B.O. and Achinihu Joy Chioma (2014). The Impact of Budget Deficits on  Macroeconomic Variables in the Nigeria Economy (1981-2012), International Journal for Innovation Education and Research,Vol 2. No. 11.

cx.   Othman, Jamal, Yaghoob Jafari and Tamat Sarmidi (2014). Economy Growth , FDI, Macroeconomic Conditions and Sustainability in Malaysia, Applied Econometrics and International Development, Vol. 14-1.

cxi. Pangestu, Mari dan Miranda S. Goeltom, (2001). Survey of Recent Development,Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol. 37. No. 2.

cxii.                       Papanek, G.F., (1972). The Effect of Aid and Other Resource Transfers on Savings and Growth in Less Developed Countries,  Economic Journal, Vol 82. No. 327.

cxiii.                     Parkins, John (2001), “Confenssion of an Economic Hitman”, Ebury Press.

cxiv.                     ---------- (2017), The Secret History of The American Empire Economic Hir Men, Jakals and the Truth About Global Corruption, Ebury Press.          

cxv.                       Qadarwi, Yusuf, (2011), “Hukum Zakat”, Mitra Kejayaan Indonesia, Cetakan Ke 12, Jakarta.

cxvi.                     Qayyum, Unbreen,. Din MuslehUd and Adnan Heider. (2014). Foreign Aid, External Debt Governance, Economic Modelling, Vol. 37.

cxvii.                   Radelet, Steven, (1995). Indonesia Foreign Debt: Headed for Crisis or Financing Sustainable Growth?,Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 3. No. 3.

cxviii.                 Radelet, Steven, (1996).Indonesian Foreign Debt: A Reply, Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 32. No. 2.

cxix.                     Rahmaddi, Rudy dan Masaru Ichihashi (2013). The Role of FDI in Indonesia’s Manufacturing Export, Bulletin of Indonesia Economic Studies, Vol. 49. No. 3.

cxx.                        Rahman N.H.A, (2012). The Relationship between Budget Deficit and Economic Growth from Malaysia’s Perspective: An ARDL Approach, available at

cxxi.                     Rana, Pradumma B. and J. Malcolm Dowling, Jr, (1988). The Impact of Foreign Capital on Growth: Evidence from Asia Developing Countries, The Developing Economies, Vol. 26. No. 1.

cxxii.                   Rana, Pradumma B. (1987). Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth in the Asia and Pacific Region, Asian Development Review, Vol. 5. No. 1.

cxxiii.                 Rangarajan, C., and D. Srivastava, (2005). Fiscal deficits and government debt in India: implications for growth and stabilization, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP),Working Paper no 35.

cxxiv.                 Rankin, N., and B. Roffia (2003). Maximum sustainable government debt in the overlapping generations model, The Manchester School 71, 217–241.

cxxv.                   Reinhart, Vincent and Brian Sack (2000). The Economic Consequenses of Disappearing Government Debt, Brooking Papers on Economic Activity: 2 (Washington: Brookings Institution), 2000.

cxxvi.                 Robinson, Joan (1979). Aspects of Development and Underdevelopment, Cambridge  University Press,

a.       Cambridge.

cxxvii.                Romer, P. (2015). Mathiness in the Theory of Economic Growth, American Economic Review, 105 (5), 89-93.

cxxviii.              ----------, (1986). Increasing returns and long-run growth, Journal of Political Economy, 94, 1002–1035.

cxxix.                 ----------, (1987). Growth based on increasing returns due to specialization, American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings 77, 56–62.

cxxx.                   ----------, (1990). Endogenous technical change”, Journal of Political Economy,98, 71–102.

cxxxi.                 Rosalinda (2012). Manajemen Resiko Investasi Wakaf Uang, Islamica, Vol. 6. No. 2. Hal. 300-3015.

cxxxii.               Roubini, N dan J. Sachs, (1989). Government Spending and Budget Deficits in the Industrial Countries”, Economic Policy. Vol 9.

cxxxiii.              Sadli, M. (1972). Foreign Investment in Developing Countries: Indonesia”, in P.        Drysdale (ed.), Direct

a.       Foreign Investment in Asia and the Pacific, Canberra,            ANU Press.

cxxxiv.               Saint-Paul, G. (1992). Fiscal policy in an endogenous growth model, Quarterly Journal of Economics 107, 1243–1259.

cxxxv.               Saleh, A.S., (2003). The Budget Deficit and Economic Performance: A Survey, Economic Working Paper Series, University of Wallongong.

cxxxvi.             Shauki, Achmad, (1995). “Integrasi Vertikal Sebagai Cara Untuk Menguasai Pasar”,

a.       dalam Alumni FEUI dan Tantangan Masa Depan Beragam Pemikiran, Gramedia,

b.      Jakarta.

cxxxvii.           Sim, A. Christoper, (1980). “Macroeconomics and Reality”, Econometrics, Vol.48, No.1. pp. 1 – 48.

cxxxviii.         Simanjuntak, R.A dan Friska P. Panjaitan, (2007). “Government Debt and Fiscal Sustainability: A Case Study of Indonesia 1998-2001”, Economics and Finance in Indonesia, Vol. 55.

cxxxix.             Simionescu, Mihaela, (2016). The Relation Between Economic Growth and FDI During the Economic Crisis in the European Union, rad.Ekon.fak.Rij, Vol. 34. No.1.

cxl. Spiegel, Samuel J. (2012). Government Institutions, Resource Rights Regimes and the Informal Mining Sector: Regulatory Complexities in Indonesia, World Development, Vol. 40. No.1

cxli.                       Siregar, Reza Y., (2001). Survey of Recent Development”, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, Vol. 37. No. 3.

cxlii.                     Stock, H. James and Watson, Mark,.(2001)., ”Vector Autoregressions”, Journal Ecocnomic Perspectives, Vol. 15. No. 4. p. 101-115.

cxliii.                   Soelistianingsih, Lana, (2012). The Indonesian Government Debt Transformation, Economics and Finance in Indonesia, Vol. 60.

cxliv.                    Soesastro, Hadi (1998). Daya Saing Industri Indonesia dalam PAJ. 1998. Daya Saing Industri Indonesia, Perhimpunan Alumni Jerman, Jakarta.

cxlv.                     Suparmoko, M., (1984). Kebijaksanaan Anggaran Pendapatan dan Belanja Negara, Prisma.

cxlvi.                   Supranto, J. (1998). Perkembangan Sektor Pertanian dan Perannya Dalam Peningkatan Ekspor Non Migas Dalam Memasuki Abad ke 21, Jurnal Ekonomi dan Pembangunan, VI (1).

cxlvii.                 Tambunan, Tulus T., (1996). Perdagangan Luar Negeri Dan Daya Saing Indonesia di Pasar   Global”, dalam Daya Saing Perekonomian Indonesia Menyongsong Era Pasar Bebas,           penyunting Tulus Tambunan, Lukman Hakim dan Budi Santoso, MEP Jakarta.

cxlviii.               ---------- (2001). Industrialisasi di Negara Berkembang: Kasus Indonesia, Ghalia      Indonesia, Jakarta.

cxlix.                    ---------- (2014). Perekonomian Indonesia, Kajian Teoritis dan Analisis Empiris, Ghalia             Indonesia,Jakarta.

cl.     Tan, E. C., (2006). Fiscal Deficits, Inflation and Economic Growth in a Successful Open Developing Economy, Review of Applied Economics, Vol.2, No.1, pp: 129-139.

cli.   Tarmidi, Lepi T. dan Muliadi Widjaya, (2000). Tinjauan Triwulanan Perekonomian Indonesia, Ekonomi Keuangan Indonesia, Vol. XLVIII, No. 4.

clii. Taylor, L. et al., (2012). Fiscal deficits, economic growth and government debt in the USA, Cambridge Journal of Economics, Vol.36, No.1, pp: 189–204.

cliii.                       Weiskoff, E., (1972). The Impact of Foreign Capital Inflow on Domestic Savings in Under developed Countries, Journal of International Economics, Vol. 2.

cliv.                       Todaro, M, dan Stephen C. Smith (2011). Ekonomi Pembangunan, Edisi ke 11 (Edisi             Terjemahan). Erlangga, Jakarta.

clv. Tokunbo S. Osinubi and OlaleruOledele E., (2006). Budget Deficit, External Debt and Economic Growth in Nigeria, Applied Econometric and International Development, Vol 6. No. 3.

clvi.                       Van der Eng, Pierre, (2010). The Sources of Long Term Economic Growth in Indonesia 1880-2008. Exploration in Economic History, Vol. 47. No. 3

clvii.                     Van Wijnbergen, Sweder, (1989). External Debt, Inflation, and the Piblic Sector: Toward Fiscal Policy for Sustainable Growth, The World Bank Economic Review, Vol. 3, No. 3, 1989.

clviii.                   Varian, Hal. (2014). Microeconomic Analysis, 3rd Edition. Norton.

clix.                       Wei, William W.S. (1990). Time Series Analysis Univariaet and Multivariate Methods. United             States: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company. 

clx. Widarjono A. (2005). Ekonometrika Teori dan Aplikasi untuk Ekonomi dan Bisnis. Yogyakarta: Ekonisia. 

clxi.                       ---------- (2007). Ekonometrika Teori dan Aplikasi untuk Ekonomi dan Bisnis. Edisi Kedua. Yogyakarta: Ekonisia.

clxii.                     World Bank, (1988). World Development Report.

clxiii.                   ---------- (1993). Indonesia Industrial Policy Shifting into High Gear.

clxiv.                   ---------- (1987). Indonesia: Sustaining High Growth with Equity, World Bank, Washington D.C.

clxv.                     Yaumidin, Umi Karomah, (2011), “Assesing The Role of Zakat for Poverty Allevation in Indonesia”, Review of Indonesian Economic and Business Studies, Vol.2. No.1. June.

clxvi.                    Zouhaier, Hadhek and Mrad Fatma (2014). Debt and Economic Growth, Intermational Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, Vol. 4. No. 2.

Cite this Article: